Panel question

A calling as untested disappointment

Kind
Quote or abstract

Prompt

A friend who left a career in engineering after ten years says to you, "A calling is just a job that has not disappointed you yet." How would you respond?

Practice this question

After you practice: what this question tests and how to approach it

What this question tests

  • Critical thinking
  • Self-reflection and growth

How to approach this question

This panel interview question tests whether you can engage with a cynical view of your motivation for medicine without getting defensive or sounding naive. Take your friend's point seriously, since many people do lose their sense of calling, and his ten years of experience deserve respect. Then explain where you agree and where you differ, using what you've actually seen of medicine's hard parts. Describe what you think sustains people through disappointment, such as relationships with patients, meaningful work and supportive colleagues, and how you plan to protect those in your own career. Avoid claiming you'll never be disappointed. Finish with a clear, honest response you could give to the friend himself.

All 13 questions on this topic

Mock interviews

If you want to practice with a person, we run mock MMI and panel interviews with feedback on every answer.