Panel question

Advance requests for assisted dying

Kind
Policy and health systems

Prompt

Some places allow a person who is suffering near the end of life to request help to die. Should a person be able to make that request years in advance, to take effect once they can no longer recognize their family, even if by then they seem content?

Practice this question

After you practice: what this question tests and how to approach it

What this question tests

  • Ethical reasoning
  • Critical thinking

How to approach this question

This panel interview question tests whether you can weigh a person's earlier wishes against the person they've become, one of the hardest tensions in debates about assisted dying and end-of-life care. Name both sides of the same person: the self who made the request while able to decide, and the later self who seems content but no longer recognizes family. Consider the family, who may disagree, and the people who'd be asked to carry out the request. Ask which safeguards might matter, such as how specific the request was and who would decide when it takes effect. Weigh respect for autonomy against the duty to protect someone who can't speak for themselves now. Then give a clear position and acknowledge why thoughtful people reach the opposite conclusion.

Mock interviews

If you want to practice with a person, we run mock MMI and panel interviews with feedback on every answer.