How to answer an opt-in vs opt-out organ donation question in a medical school interview
- Topic
- Consent and autonomy
- Kind
- Policy and health systems
Prompt
Some places treat every adult as an organ donor after death unless they have registered to opt out, while others count only people who have actively signed up. Which approach better respects individual choice, and which would you support?
Practice this question
Answer it yourself first. The approach to this question opens below when your feedback arrives.
How to approach this question
What this question tests
- Ethical reasoning
- Health systems and advocacy
- Critical thinking
How to approach it
This panel question tests whether you can tell the difference between respecting a person's choice and making one choice easier than the other. Explain both organ donation systems clearly: opt-in counts only people who sign up, and opt-out treats everyone as a donor unless they register otherwise. Consider whether silence really counts as consent, and how well informed people are under each approach. Weigh the potential for more donors against the risk that people who never knew the rule are counted anyway. Think about the role families play when the decision arrives. Land on a clear position, and explain how you'd protect each person's ability to choose.
More on consent and autonomy
All 9 questions on this topicMock interviews
Practice with a real interviewer
A real interviewer asks questions, records the interview so you can review it together, and gives feedback on your content and delivery.
