Panel question

Supervisor requests reviews of her textbook

Kind
Ethical dilemma

Prompt

Your research supervisor, who has agreed to write your reference letter for medical school next month, asks everyone in the lab to post a five-star review of her new textbook on a bookselling website. You have read only two chapters of it. What would you do?

Practice this question

After you practice: what this question tests and how to approach it

What this question tests

  • Professionalism and integrity
  • Communication
  • Ethical reasoning

How to approach this question

This panel question tests whether you'll stay honest when the person asking a favor holds power over your medical school application. Name the conflict of interest directly: a five-star review of a book you've mostly not read would mislead buyers, while refusing could feel risky with your reference letter due next month. A strong answer considers what an honest response looks like, such as finishing the book and writing a genuine review, or declining politely and in private. Think about how to raise your concern with your supervisor respectfully, since she may not have considered how the request looks, and whether other students in the lab feel the same pressure. Commit to what you'd actually do, and explain how you'd handle it if she reacted badly.

All 8 questions on this topic

Mock interviews

If you want to practice with a person, we run mock MMI and panel interviews with feedback on every answer.